Subscribe to GEN
Login to GEN
Add a Comment
What a sheet of office paper costs in energy and water before it reaches the tray, what a workhorse printer really costs per page, per week and per year, and why, fifty years after the paperless office was promised, finance teams are still printing invoices
6.8p a page. £1,127 a year per printer. Up to £170,000 a year for an estate of 150. And that is before the 20 to 50Wh of energy and 10 litres of water in every sheet, or a machine that takes five times more energy to build than it will ever use.
We still walk into organisations running well over a hundred printers. Not print rooms, not a reprographics department: printers, one under every other desk, a multifunction on every floor, and a cupboard of toner that nobody can quite account for.
And then you watch what they are used for. A supplier invoice arrives by email as a PDF. Someone in finance prints it. Someone scans it. The scan is emailed to the budget holder, who prints it "for their files", signs it, and sends it back, where it is scanned again for the accounts system. One document, born digital, has been turned into paper twice and back into a PDF twice, and every step has been carried out by a person who is paid to do something else.
This is not an eco-warrior post. It is an accounting one. A printed page carries two bills: the one you pay, which is larger than most people think, and the one everybody else pays, which is larger still. Both are worth adding up.
A page that started life as a PDF and ends life as a PDF has no business being paper in the middle.
A ream of A4 at 80gsm weighs about 2.5kg, so each sheet is roughly 5 grams. That sheet has been on quite a journey.
Published figures for the energy needed to make a tonne of virgin paper range from about 4MWh (electricity and steam at a modern mill) to about 10MWh (total primary energy across the supply chain). The spread is about where you draw the boundary, not a disagreement about the physics. Either way, the numbers come out like this:
| Quantity | Paper | Embodied energy | Water footprint |
|---|---|---|---|
| One sheet | 5g | 20 to 50Wh | about 10 litres |
| One ream (500 sheets) | 2.5kg | 10 to 25kWh | about 5,000 litres |
| One box (2,500 sheets) | 12.5kg | 50 to 125kWh | about 25,000 litres |
The water figure is the Water Footprint Network's global average for an A4 sheet. Most of it is rain taken up by the forest rather than water drawn from a river, and the real range runs from about 2 to 30 litres depending on where the wood grew, but it gives a sense of scale. A single ream of paper carries roughly the energy needed to run a 2kW kettle for somewhere between five and twelve hours.
Hold on to that number, because in a moment it will make the printer's own electricity bill look like a rounding error.
To keep this honest we have used a real, independently reviewed life cycle assessment rather than marketing copy: Lexmark's ISO 14040/14044 study of its CX622adhe, a 40 page-per-minute A4 colour laser multifunction. It is a sensible proxy for the workhorse found on almost every office floor, and other manufacturers' machines of the same class are broadly similar. Over its assumed five year life the study models roughly 83,000 pages, about 16,600 a year or 320 a week.
Two things stand out. First, it takes about five times more energy to make the printer than it will ever use plugged into the wall. Second, a year's paper for that one machine, 16,600 sheets or about 83kg, carries somewhere between 330 and 830kWh of embodied energy. The printer's own electricity, at 31kWh, is the smallest line on the sheet. Switching printers off at night is fine; it is not where the problem is.
Now multiply by the estate. A hundred and fifty machines of this class represent about four tonnes of hardware, around 26 tonnes of CO2e and some 115MWh of energy just to manufacture, and the whole lot is replaced every five years or so.
Printers are a poor bet for repair. Parts are model-specific, support windows are short, and a failed formatter board or fuser on a machine past its warranty is usually the end of it. The machine becomes e-waste. The UN's Global E-waste Monitor 2024 put worldwide e-waste at 62 million tonnes in 2022, of which only 22.3% was documented as properly collected and recycled. Small equipment fares worst. The steel is recoverable; much of the mixed plastic is not, and what is not recovered is landfilled or burned.
The printer is a one-off. The consumables are a subscription to waste.
In the Lexmark study, cartridges and toner are the largest contributor to the printer's use-phase carbon once paper is set aside, ahead of the electricity used to run it.
Every printed page ends up somewhere, usually within days, and there are only three places it can go: the general waste bin, the paper recycling box, or the confidential waste console. Far too much of it goes in the first.
When WRAP analysed the general waste thrown away by businesses in Wales, paper and card was the single largest material in it, at 25.7%, ahead of plastics and food. Three quarters of everything in those bins could have been recycled or composted. The law has since caught up: Wales has required every workplace to separate paper and card since 6 April 2024, and under Simpler Recycling, England has required it of workplaces with ten or more employees since 31 March 2025. But a duty to provide the box is not the same thing as people using it.
Paper in the right box is far better than paper in the wrong one, but it is not the closed loop people imagine:
This is where the environmental problem becomes a security one. An invoice is not just paper. It carries a supplier's name, address and bank details, your purchase order numbers, the names of the people who raise and approve payments, and very often a signature. That is exactly the material a fraudster needs for the payment diversion attack we described in 20260808.
Once it leaves the desk, unshredded paper passes through far more hands than anyone imagines:
The regulator has seen all of this before. In 2012 the ICO fined Scottish Borders Council £250,000 after pension records, including salary and bank details, were found in an overfilled paper recycling bank outside a supermarket, dumped there by the contractor paid to digitise them. The fine was later overturned at tribunal, but the files had already been found by a member of the public. In 2019 a London pharmacy, Doorstep Dispensaree, received the first UK fine under the GDPR after crates, bags and boxes of patient documents were found unlocked behind its premises. The penalty was £275,000, reduced to £92,000 on appeal. Unshredded paper in the wrong place is a personal data breach, whatever colour the bin was.
Shredding fixes the security problem and makes the recycling problem worse. A confidential waste contract fixes both, at a price, and only for the paper that actually reaches the console. The only option that fixes everything is not to create the paper in the first place.
Every invoice you print is another copy of your supplier's bank details that you now have to destroy securely.
This is the figure most organisations never work out, because it never arrives as a single invoice. The printer is a capital purchase, the toner is on the stationery budget, the paper is on another, the service contract sits with IT, and the electricity disappears into the building. Nobody sees the total, so here it is for that same workhorse machine, at UK business prices excluding VAT:
| Cost line | Basis | Per year |
|---|---|---|
| The printer | about £750, written off over 5 years | £150 |
| Toner and imaging | 13,280 mono pages at 1.8p, 3,320 colour at 13.5p (80/20 split, manufacturer's quoted running costs) | £687 |
| Paper | 16,600 sheets at about 0.8p | £132 |
| Service, fuser and maintenance kits | after the first year's warranty (estimate) | £150 |
| Electricity | 31kWh at about 26p | £8 |
| Total | £1,127 |
That is about 6.8p per page, £21.70 per week and £1,127 per year, for one machine, before anyone's time is counted. Note again where electricity sits: less than one per cent of the total.
The lightly used desk printer is worse, not better. Its fixed costs, purchase and service, do not shrink because nobody uses it, and its small cartridges have the worst cost per page in the range. Spread £300 of fixed cost over 2,000 pages a year and every page costs 15p before a single gram of toner is applied.
Scale that to an estate of 150 devices, a realistic mix of busy multifunctions and quiet desk printers, and you are looking at somewhere between £75,000 and £170,000 a year to put marks on paper. And that still leaves out the costs that never appear on any printing budget:
Take a finance team handling 400 supplier invoices a week through the print, scan, email, print routine. At a minimum that is two printed sheets per invoice, and multi-page invoices make it more:
None of it adds control. The approval is no more valid on paper than it is in an accounts system with a proper audit trail; it is considerably less so, because a paper signature cannot tell you who approved what, when, and from where. HMRC accepts electronic invoices and digital records, and Making Tax Digital already requires VAT records to be kept digitally. The paper copy is a duplicate of something you are obliged to hold digitally anyway.
There is a fine irony in the history. In 1959 Xerox launched the 914, the first practical plain-paper office copier, and through the 1960s it did more than any other machine to bury offices in paper. By 1975 the same company was predicting the opposite. In the 30 June 1975 issue of BusinessWeek, under the headline "The Office of the Future", George Pake, head of Xerox's Palo Alto Research Center, described desks equipped with screens and keyboards, linked to each other and to electronic filing, with workers calling up documents on screen rather than handling paper. The "paperless office" entered the business vocabulary.
Almost every part of that prediction came true. Every desk has a screen. Every document is created electronically, travels electronically and is stored electronically. The only part that did not come true is the part that required people to stop pressing Print.
Fifty years later, in 2026, we still find organisations printing invoices that arrived as PDFs.
GEN banned printers across its entire estate in 2015. Not reduced, not "managed": removed. And everything carried on. Invoices were approved, contracts were signed, accounts were filed, and nobody has asked for one back. What we gained was a shorter supplier list, fewer support calls, one less class of networked device to secure, and a filing system that can actually be searched.
We are not suggesting every organisation can switch off every printer tomorrow. But almost every organisation can switch off most of them, and the first step costs nothing: add up the real bill, per page, per week and per year, put it in front of whoever signs off the stationery budget, and then ask the finance team why the invoice needs to be paper at all.
The technology to stop printing has existed for fifty years. We all need to do better at using it.
This content is not legal or financial advice, and is solely the opinion of the author.